Seeking input, SDCCD redistricting subcommittee reveals proposed maps

The district is calling for public comment on new maps and a change to the election process

A slide from the SDCCD redistricting subcommittee meeting shows a map with arrows indicating the three proposed adjusted boundaries under consideration. Zoom screenshot

A slide from the SDCCD redistricting subcommittee meeting shows the three proposed adjusted boundaries under consideration. Zoom screenshot

Kathy Archibald, Multimedia Journalist

Once-in-a-decade democracy officially arrived at the San Diego Community College District on Monday with the unveiling of potential new subdistrict boundaries.

The SDCCD Board of Trustees redistricting subcommittee asked the public for input during a Zoom forum Monday evening, providing a first glimpse of its new proposed district map and an explanation of the process.

“For our district, we speak of trustee areas (also referred to as subdistricts). We have five of them, A through E,” SDCCD Director of Legal Services Ljubisa Kostic said.

The goal with any adjustment is, “to make sure that each area is representing as close to an equal number of voters as we can while at the same time making sure that we preserve communities of interest, and that we have fair and balanced voting in terms of racial, demographic and political makeup,” Kostic said.

A slide from the Board of Trustees redistricting subcommittee meeting shows the current population imbalance among the five subdistricts of the SDCCD based on 2020 census data. Zoom screenshot
A slide from the Board of Trustees redistricting subcommittee meeting shows the current population imbalance among the five subdistricts of the SDCCD based on 2020 census data. Zoom screenshot

SDCCD trustee Bernie Rhinerson, who represents Area B and is a member of the redistricting subcommittee, explained that the district overall has increased in population by approximately 10,000 people since the 2010 census. However, that growth has come disproportionately in his subdistrict, creating an imbalance.

“The charge that was given to the board subcommittee of Geysil and myself was to balance those out,” Rhinerson said.

The recommended adjustments would shift part of the line between Areas B and D, and two portions of the boundary between Areas B and E, leaving Areas A and C unchanged, Rhinerson said.

A map shows the first proposed adjustment area discussed at the SDCCD redistricting meeting, moving residents in San Carlos from Area B to Area D. Youtube screenshot
A map shows the first proposed adjustment area discussed at the SDCCD redistricting meeting, moving residents in San Carlos from Area B to Area D. Youtube screenshot

A section of Area B south of Navajo Road in San Carlos including 11,809 San Diegans would be shifted into Area D, he said.

Geysil Arroyo, the board member who represents Area E, explained the other two shifts, which would affect her district.

A map shows the second proposed adjustment area discussed at the SDCCD redistricting meeting, moving residents in Kensington from Area D to Area E. Youtube screenshot
A map shows the second proposed adjustment area discussed at the SDCCD redistricting meeting, moving residents in Kensington from Area D to Area E. Youtube screenshot

A portion of Kensington between Adams Avenue and El Cajon Boulevard would shift 5,342 San Diegans from Area D to Area E, and 3,500 residents near 47th Street between Home Avenue and Palm Avenue would also shift from Area D to Area E, Arroyo said.

A map shows the third proposed adjustment area discussed at the SDCCD redistricting meeting, moving residents near Chollas View from Area D to Area E. Youtube screenshot
A map shows the third proposed adjustment area discussed at the SDCCD redistricting meeting, moving residents near Chollas View from Area D to Area E. Youtube screenshot

With these changes the difference between the smallest and largest subdistricts would shift from 11.47% to 2.18%, bringing the districts significantly closer to equal in size, and well below the goal deviation of 10% or less, Rhinerson said.

Rhinerson also showed a chart with a breakdown of ethnicity among subdistricts. He said there are, “very small adjustments in these percentages, really less than a percent and a half, so very little change in the ethnic composition by subdistrict as a result of these changes.”

No attendees made public comments during the Monday meeting. 

The public can still weigh in on these changes by submitting a comment on the SDCCD website or commenting at the next special board meeting on Dec. 6 to be held on Zoom, according to the district website. 

The board will also discuss and vote on a proposal to eliminate primary elections and hold only a general election for trustees at the Dec. 6 meeting, Arroyo said.

The final chance for public comment on the proposed map will be during the board’s regular meeting on Dec. 16, before the map is finalized and submitted to the San Diego Registrar of Voters on Dec. 17, according to the district website.

A change which was previously voted upon by the board in 2019 will be implemented for the 2022 election. Starting next year, only voters in a potential trustee’s area will vote in the general election, Kostic said. 

Prior to 2022, the top two vote-getters in each trustee area would participate in a citywide general election, according to the SDCCD website.

Kostic said the district is among many public agencies across the country making adjustments to reflect the 2020 census data. 

Here are some of those affecting San Diego residents:

California

Congressional, State Senate, State Assembly and State Board of Equalization districts are drawn by the 2020 California Citizens Redistricting Commission, which has released preliminary draft maps. The CRC meets daily this week, accepts public comment, and plans to certify final maps by Dec. 27, according to its website.

San Diego County

County Supervisor districts are drawn by the County of San Diego Independent Redistricting Commission, which has released preliminary draft maps, and plans to finalize maps on Dec. 9. The public can participate in person, by Zoom, or by submitting eComment online, according to the IRC website.

City of San Diego

San Diego City Council districts are drawn by the Redistricting Commission, which has released draft maps, and will meet next on Dec. 7. The public can participate by attending a meeting on Zoom, commenting online or by mail, and will vote on the final map Dec. 15, according to the City of San Diego website.

For more information about the SDCCD redistricting process or to comment, click here.

Watch the full meeting here: